Skip to main content

Headline Roundup July 24th, 2023

Israeli Parliament Passes Judicial Overhaul Bill

Summary from the AllSides News Team

The Israeli Parliament, or Knesset, has passed a bill that limits judicial power, despite U.S. pressure and nationwide protests.

Key Details: The measure removes the power of the nation's Supreme Court to overrule "unreasonable government actions" and strike down ministerial appointments. Proponents argue that judicial reforms are necessary to correct an imbalance of power, with the courts intervening in political decisions. Opponents say the reforms would imperil Israel as a democracy.

Key Quote: "We have taken the first step in a historic process to correct the judicial system," said Israel's Justice Minster Yariv Levin, in congratulating the MPs on the vote.

For Context: The bill is the first piece of legislation that represents a component of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's judicial overhaul. He was able to hold his coalition together in a party-line vote on the bill after proposed compromises with Israel's largest labor union and President Isaac Herzog failed earlier in the day.

How the Media Covered it: Some left-rated sources noted that Netanyahu's judicial overhaul plan has deeply divided Israelis, and that opponents have petitioned the Israeli Supreme Court to intervene. Some right-rated sources noted that the fate of remaining judicial reform proposals is unclear.

Featured Coverage of this Story

From the Right
Netanyahu Defies Biden, Opposition Protests; Passes First Judicial Reform
Netanyahu Defies Biden, Opposition Protests; Passes First Judicial Reform

Antonio Masiello/Getty Images

News

Israel’s parliament, or Knesset, passed the first of several judicial reforms proposed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government on Monday, defying protests and pressure from the White House.

The new law prevents courts from using their own idea of “reasonableness” in blocking government policies. Critics had long argued that the “reasonableness” doctrine allowed the left-leaning judiciary to abuse its power, and that it tended to do so more often against Israel’s conservative governments.

Demonstrators wave a large Israeli flag during a protest against plans by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government...

Open on Breitbart News
Possible Paywall
From the Left
Israeli Parliament Passes Law to Limit Judicial Power
Israeli Parliament Passes Law to Limit Judicial Power

New York Times (News)

News

The Israeli Parliament passed a law on Monday that limits the Supreme Court’s ability to overturn decisions made by government ministers, completing the first stage of a wider and deeply contentious effort to curb the influence of the judiciary.

The decision capped one of the most turbulent moments in Israel’s contemporary history, as protesters blocked roads outside Parliament on Monday, attempting to disrupt a measure they called an affront to democracy, and mediators raced in vain to secure a last-minute compromise.

The furor surrounding Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s broader judicial overhaul has...

Open on New York Times (News)
Possible Paywall
From the Center
Israel judicial reform: Key bill becomes law amid mass protests
Israel judicial reform: Key bill becomes law amid mass protests

BBC News

News

Israeli MPs have passed into law a highly controversial bill despite mass protests which aimed to thwart it.

The law removes the power of the Supreme Court to overrule government actions it considers unreasonable.

It is the first in a series of bitterly contested reforms aimed at curbing the power of courts to be approved.

The planned reforms have triggered some of the biggest protests in Israel's history, with opponents warning they imperil Israel as a democracy.

The government argues that the measures are necessary to correct an imbalance in...

Open on BBC News

More headline roundups

More News about World on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right