Reflecting on the Taliban's Afghanistan Takeover, 1 Year Later
Summary from the AllSides News Team
It's been one year since the Taliban took over Afghanistan and the U.S. ended its two-decade effort to democratize the country.
A year later, Afghanistan remains highly unstable. Despite pledges from the new Taliban government to make women "very active within our society," girls have been prevented from going to school in some cases, and "underground schools" have emerged as a result. Per capita income in the country is roughly $375 per year, its lowest point in more than a decade. The United Nations says that roughly 20 million Afghans are facing food insecurity.
Terrorism remains a concern as well. The assassination of al Qaeda's leader in a wealthy Kabul, Afghanistan neighborhood two weeks ago sparked questions about whether the Taliban was harboring terrorist groups. Meanwhile, U.S. officials continue to negotiate with the Taliban on releasing billions in foreign-held Afghan central bank assets.
In their reflections on the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan and the Taliban's takeover, voices from left-rated media outlets often focused more on human rights concerns in Afghanistan, such as widespread hunger, the treatment of women, and the targeting of political dissidents. Right-rated voices tended to concentrate on criticisms of Biden's handling of the situation and concerns that Afghanistan's instability will enable the emergence of powerful terrorist groups.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Violence, hunger and fear: Afghanistan under the TalibanIt was a stunning rout.
A year ago Monday, a ragtag army of extremists swept into Kabul without firing a shot after having seized most of Afghanistan. After spending trillions on military and humanitarian aid, the two-decade U.S.-led international campaign to remake the desperately poor and violence-ridden country was over.
Western nations raced to depart in a largely chaotic and embarrassing exit, and the victorious Taliban, whose previous government was toppled in the aftermath of 9/11 after refusing to hand over the author of the attack, Osama bin Laden, promised to form an “open, inclusive Islamic government.”
Instead,...
From the Center
A year after Biden's Afghanistan exit, accountability in short supplyAs weary U.S. military planners wrapped up the evacuation and pullout from Afghanistan one year ago, officials across the government steeled themselves for intense public scrutiny into how America's longest war ended in shambles with the Taliban retaking power.
But as the United States marks the first anniversary of the withdrawal this month, some U.S. officials and experts say President Joe Biden's administration has moved on without properly assessing lessons from the 20-year war and the Taliban victory.
Nor has there been public accountability for the chaotic evacuation operation that...
From the Right
Biden's enduring Afghanistan debacleGen. Frank McKenzie, the head of U.S. Central Command when Afghanistan’s capital, Kabul, fell to jihadists on Aug. 15, 2021, recently told Politico : "My belief is we should have stayed. I believe that everything that happened flowed from that basic decision [to withdraw]." McKenzie is quite right about this.
President Joe Biden and his surrogates have sometimes allowed that mistakes were made in the execution of the withdrawal from Afghanistan. How could they not after scenes of Afghans falling from moving planes and the massacre of 200 people at the Kabul airport by the...
AllSides Picks
April 19th, 2024
April 19th, 2024
April 18th, 2024
April 15th, 2024