Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 19th, 2023

What’s the Most Likely Outcome of an Israeli Invasion of Gaza?

Summary from the AllSides News Team

With Israeli forces preparing to invade Gaza, voices across the spectrum are speculating the potential outcome of an Israeli occupation of the region.

Springing the Trap: A piece in the Daily Beast (Left bias) argued an Israeli invasion would “give Hamas a chance to fight on their own turf where they can neutralize much of the IDF’s [Israeli Defense Forces] technological advantage.” Determining there to be no good outcome in sight, the writer concludes, “willing to pay a price to prevent another, Israel has apparently decided the only way out of the trap is to spring it.”

Return to Normal Life: An article in the Wall Street Journal Opinion (Lean Right bias) argued it’s “possible for a decent Gaza-led administration to emerge, which could make autonomy and even statehood possible.” Citing a poll determining “62% of Gazans wanted to keep a cease-fire with Israel and half wanted Hamas to stop calling for Israel’s destruction,” the writer argues Israel could “find plenty of residents ready to work with the new authority to create an administration that could return them to normal life.”

“Ruthless Pursuit of Peace”: A piece published in The Hill (Center bias) argued against an invasion of Gaza, instead pushing for expanded peace-talks in the region that “cannot happen if Israel marches into Gaza with guns blazing and tanks rumbling.” The writer argues the U.S. should incentivize Israel not to invade Gaza by fast-tracking its peace deal with Saudi Arabia, advocating for a “ruthless pursuit of peace.”

Featured Coverage of this Story

Every Option for Israel in Gaza Is Bad
Every Option for Israel in Gaza Is Bad

Doaa Albaz/Anadolu via Getty Images

Opinion

In response to the Oct. 7 Hamas attack in Israel that killed at least 1,400, mostly civilians, and kidnapped about 150 more, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) are firing airstrikes into Hamas-controlled Gaza and massing for a ground invasion. But critics fear the worst, and urge otherwise.

“Israel is walking into a trap,” writes Hussein Ibish in The Atlantic, warning that Hamas and its regional supporters want Israel to send forces into Gaza, thinking the mass suffering it inevitably causes will do more harm to Israel’s position than theirs.

Hamas...

Open on Daily Beast
A smarter way to proceed in Gaza: hold off and reengage Riyadh
A smarter way to proceed in Gaza: hold off and reengage Riyadh

AP Photo/Susan Walsh, File

Opinion

The Oct. 7 Hamas massacre has inspired two new tidbits of conventional wisdom: first, that Israel will now launch a ground invasion of Gaza to remove Hamas from power, and second that the U.S.-brokered peace deal between Israel and Saudi Arabia is for the moment off the table. 

Both of these assumptions should be reexamined.

A better path forward may be to fast-track such a peace deal and even expand it. The shrewdest answer to the savagery of Hamas — to an unprovoked assault which was almost certainly green-lighted by...

Open on The Hill
A Decent Outcome Is Possible in Gaza
A Decent Outcome Is Possible in Gaza

Hasan Islayeh/Associated Press

Opinion

Everyone seems to agree that no good outcome is possible in Gaza. They’re wrong. It’s possible for a decent Gaza-led administration to emerge, which could make autonomy and even statehood possible.

That may seem unlikely, given the deep and longstanding anti-Zionism in Gaza. In 1967, Gazan school books taught arithmetic with problems like, “You have five Israelis. You kill three of them. How many Israelis are left to be killed?”

But over the past 15 years, Gazans have endured something monstrous and possibly unique in human experience: exploitation by their...

Open on Wall Street Journal (Opinion)

More headline roundups

More News about Middle East on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right