Who Ordered Ukraine's Starshield Restrictions? Reports Offer Conflicting Accounts

Conflicting reports have emerged around the restrictions placed on Starshield use in Ukraine's war against Russia.

For Context: Ukraine accused Elon Musk's SpaceX of throttling Starlink technology last week, which it said impeded both frontline operations and defense capabilities against Russian attacks. Musk refuted these claims, saying, "Starshield systems are owned and controlled by the US government." US officials including President Donald Trump have denied Musk's accusations.

'Mystery and Conflicting Reports': The New York Post (Right bias) highlighted "a series of reports" that "have offered conflicting explanations." According to the article, "Reuters cited sources claiming instructions came from the White House," while "a subsequent Telegraph story said Musk approached Trump with the idea and a prior WSJ report fingered Musk." Trump administration sources reportedly told the Post that "there was continued uncertainty about what happened to cause the initial slowdown, with one theory being that Ukraine may have experienced slowdowns due to using versions of Starlink, a consumer project, instead of Starshield." The Post also noted that there is "no evidence to prove that speculation." Trump also called Musk on Wednesday asking him to "fully reverse any limits to crucial internet services," and according to the coverage Starshield "has improved" but is "not yet at full functionality."

'Came As A Surprise': Some outlets on the left, like CBS News (Lean Left) and CNBC (Lean Left), highlighted a Wall Street Journal (Center) claim that it was Musk who ordered the service changes. CBS opened coverage by citing "people familiar with the matter" who said that a "decision by Elon Musk led to restrictions on Ukraine's use of SpaceX satellite communications network." According to CBS, "the temporary restrictions came as a surprise to some officials inside the administration, who said neither Mr. Trump nor the Pentagon specifically ordered any limits meant to deliberately disrupt drone operations and battlefield communications." CNBC called the service changes "Elon Musk's latest clash with Ukraine."

'I Have A Bridge In Kyiv To Sell You': Author Andrew C. McCarthy (Right) for National Review Opinion (Right) said that "Trump and 'War' Secretary Pete Hegseth figure you've forgotten, or were simply paying no attention, to their attempt to destroy Anthropic" because it risked allowing military decisions to be made by non-government employees. According to McCarthy, "The Starshield controversy presents the same situation," adding that "the implication that the administration would cede decision-making about how technology is deployed on the battlefield to Musk, an unelected tech executive, is ridiculous." McCarthy said, "If you believe Elon Musk unilaterally gave the order to impose speed restrictions in Ukraine," then "I have a bridge in Kyiv to sell you…if Putin hasn't blown it to smithereens already."

RELATED: Witkoff Meets Putin and Zelenskyy: American Prisoner Freed, Zelenskyy Open to Freezing Conflict

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission. Suggest an improvement to this summary.