Sign up for Dan’s new weekly newsletter and podcast, "Sanity Check," at danschnur.substack.com. Politics… but calmer. And you can read more of Dan’s writing at www.danschnurpolitics.com.
A review of modern political history reminds us that it’s been quite a while since national Democrats have faced a truly consequential political decision. Kamala Harris’ selection as their presidential nominee two years ago was presented to them as a done deal, without any discussion or debate. Joe Biden’s withdrawal from the race required a great deal of private persuasion, but rank-and-file party members had no say in the matter.
Going back further, Biden’s nomination was orchestrated by party leaders who organized the centrist candidates in the 2020 primary to close ranks around him to shut down the possibility of an unelectable progressive like Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren emerging as the party’s standard-bearer. And four years before that, Democratic National Committee insiders and operatives made sure that Sanders could not topple Hillary Clinton.
Which means that the 2008 primary campaign in which Barack Obama defeated Clinton might have been the last time Democrats as a party have confronted such a difficult and defining set of choices as those presently before them. Before Gavin Newsom and Pete Buttigieg and dozens of others of aspirants determine who will lead their party into a general election fray against the first Republican nominee of the post-Trump era, the Democrats in Washington, who are temporarily the most visible members of their party, will spend the next year determining how their brand will be considered—or reconsidered—by a weary America electorate.
They must decide whether they wish to be seen as fighters or as unifiers, whether to focus their attention on the kitchen table issues that elected their most centrist candidates or on a wider-ranging and more ambitious agenda to animate their most loyal supporters. Are they about affordability or impeachment, about battling Trump or seeking common ground, or about bridge-building or earth-scorching?
The party’s establishment leaders want to proceed cautiously and avoid the possibility of voter backlash. The younger, more progressive, and less patient voices have little interest in waiting any longer. Even before the confetti from election night victory parties had been swept away, those tensions were becoming evident. They have now exploded into full view, and we will learn in the next few weeks which of these Democratic parties most Democrats want to be.
The most evident face of change right now is Senator Chris Van Hollen, the progressive Marylander who announced last week his intention to challenge Chuck Schumer for the position of Senate Majority Leader in the new Congress. Van Hollen is not only well to the left of Schumer but also embodies a generational and attitudinal shift that has already taken over the party’s grassroots activist base. The result of his challenge will tell us volumes about how Democrats intend to behave for the remainder of the Trump presidency.
But the leadership battle is only a prelude to even more consequential clashes that will follow shortly thereafter. In early December, Congress must act to provide sufficient funding to prevent a government shutdown. The angriest Democrats see that as an opportunity to withdraw funding for a continuation of the Iran war, even at the risk of a shutdown. While public opinion is overwhelmingly with them on the war, more cautious party members are wary that headlines of a government closure would distract from voters’ interest in legislation directed at their economic and inflation concerns. No elected Democrat wants the Iran war to continue, but the timing of their response deeply divides the Schumer and Van Hollen wings of the party.
By early next year, an even bigger dilemma will need to be resolved. Democratic leaders, like their rank-and-file, despise Trump. But they worry that a presidential impeachment would frustrate voters hungry for relief from skyrocketing gasoline and food prices. Party activists are thirsty for Trump’s blood, though, and even a very determined party elder might not be able to resist such high levels of pent-up emotion and such a deep desire for retribution.
Internal disagreements over health care, immigration, transgender policy, and Gaza await as well, not to mention the looming firestorm over data centers, China, and other aspects of the artificial intelligence debate. The next Democratic presidential nominee will determine the direction the party takes on these and other issues—but not for another eighteen months or so. In the meantime, there is work to be done. And a party’s reputation to repair.