American rapper Macklemore was kicked off the remainder of Ed Sheeran's stadium tour after expressing pro-Palestinian views at a show in New Jersey earlier this month.
The Insight provides you the full picture of facts and viewpoints on a top issue for Americans each week, powered by your questions and balanced answers from our multipartisan news team.
The Questions
Why did Macklemore get kicked off Ed Sheeranâs Loop Tour?
During his performance at MetLife Stadium on September 4, Macklemore said, âFree Palestine. I want those words to be loud and clear, so the people from Gaza all the way to the occupied West Bank know that we have not forgotten.â
On September 5, during another performance at MetLife, he addressed Jewish audience members and said, âCriticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide in no way is a criticism of you. My message is for peace, love; for all human beings to be treated with dignity, respect, and equality.â
Macklemoreâs onstage comments prompted critical posts from the StopAntisemitism activist organization, one of which was amplified by pop singer P!nk.
Macklemore later said on Instagram that Sheeran contacted him after a conversation with Robert Kraft about Macklemoreâs comments on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Kraft owns the New England Patriots and Gillette Stadium in Massachusetts, where the tour is scheduled to stop later this month.
Macklemore alleged that Kraft told Sheeran that Macklemore would not be allowed to perform at his stadium and that he was given the choice between cancelling the show or removing Macklemore from the performance. Additionally, Macklemore claimed that Kraft rallied other stadium owners to maintain this position for their venues as well.
Kraft released a statement that said the decision to ban Macklemore came because of his recent comments âand a broader history of antisemitic rhetoric and imagery that we believe has been deeply offensive and hurtful to the Jewish community.â Both P!nk and Kraft are Jewish Americans.
In Sheeranâs own Instagram post about the issue, Sheeran alleged that the decision to remove Macklemore from the tour came from the promoter rather than himself. He also claimed that Kraftâs stance âwas based on how Macklemore conveyed part of his message⌠rather than on everything that was said.â
Sheeran wrote, âThere is a reason I do not use my professional platform for politics â my audience includes young people, often children, of all backgrounds. Those who come to my shows do not expect a political forum. I respect Macklemore's strength of purpose to stand up and shout for what he believes. However, there is room for multiple approaches to the same end: peace. I choose to use my fame and platform to be a place of safety and sanctuary, to maintain diplomacy and keep conversations open, not closed.â
Macklemore described Sheeran as a longtime âfriendâ who âwas in a f***ed up positionâ because âhis typical apolitical stance was being challenged in a way it never had been before.â He also criticized what he described as the weaponization of antisemitism accusations, and concluded, âI didn't need 10 shows from Ed. I needed 2. Two chances to stand in front of 90,000 people and say the words that somehow became too dangerous to say. Free Palestine. But if those words cost me the stage, while turning the conversation back to Palestine, then it was the most successful tour I've ever been on.â
Macklemoreâs comments did not come out of nowhere, however. The artist has previously voiced support for Palestinian freedom, given speeches at performances about the subject, and has projected images of the Palestinian flag on stage.
His music has never shied away from political and social themes. In 2012, he and creative partner Ryan Lewis released the pro-gay rights song âSame Love,â and in 2016 he released âWhite Privilege II,â which commented on police brutality and Black Lives Matter.
In 2014, Macklemore dressed in a costume that many argued resembled a Jewish man and was antisemitic, though Macklemore later apologized and said he didn't mean to offend anyone.
How have the media and politicians reacted?
Macklemoreâs decision has received praise from many Democratic lawmakers and commentators, and fellow celebrities. Some conservative voices were more critical.
Fox News (Right) cited Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) thanking Macklemore for speaking up and saying, âThis is a moment for us to come together, find our moral conscience as a nation, and end this genocide.â It also mentioned criticism from childrenâs YouTuber, Ms. Rachel, who said, âEd SheeranâŚcaved to people who refuse to accept what the world knows.â Music artist Finneas also announced his decision to withdraw from Sheeranâs tour on Instagram, writing, âArtists must not be silenced when they speak up for the oppressed.â Fox and Newsweek (Center) listed other prominent figures whoâve backed Macklemore, including Pink Floydâs Roger Waters, Rep. Ro Khanna (D-CA), Rosie OâDonnell and Lukas Graham.
Some have argued that the decision to remove him from the tour threatens freedom of speech. Aaron Terr from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) (Center) said that two stadiums where Macklemore had been scheduled to perform were publicly owned and operated, meaning âthey have to comply with the First Amendmentâ and âcanât cancel a performance just because they disagree with the artistâs views.â Terr noted, however, that if the stadiums werenât involved in the decision, there would be no First Amendment violation. Terr also warned this precedent could lead to âany artist who expresses a controversial political view find[ing] it difficult to get on stage.â
A Mother Jones (Left) article argued that the dispute is a âcorporate threat to free speech.â It said while the venues are publicly owned, the corporate branding and âbillionaire team ownersâ have âbecome a mechanism for corporate censorship of political speech.â Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) echoed this argument in an interview with TMZ, saying, âIt's become clear that this is not just about one music artist or two music artists, but this is about how just a handful of stadium owners and the elite can prevent an entire massive issue.â An opinion writer in MS Now (Left) said the debate âexposes the galling hypocrisy of those who profess to be the most opposed to so-called cancel culture.â
An opinion writer in The Spectator (Right) criticized accusations of âcensorship,â saying, âI thought âfreeze peachâ was the cry of racist gammons and cancel culture an invention of the far right? This is the problem with progressives: theyâre so busy progressing they never stand in the same philosophical spot for longer than five minutes.â The writer downplayed Macklemore as an artist, describing him as a âboreâ and saying he âsounds like an ideal warm-up for a middle-of-the-road peddler of romantic popâ before arguing that âThe accusation that Israel is committing a genocide in Gaza isâŚnot the cry of street revolutionaries amid clouds of tear gas; itâs the cry of school teachers and church ladies amid Facebook posts about their grandchildren and their dachshunds.â