U.S. Women’s Early FIFA Exit Highlights Political Division and Culture War
Summary from the AllSides News Team
The U.S. women’s World Cup team - which is known for being politically outspoken - was upset by Sweden this week, drawing mixed media reactions.
Roster & Parity: An opinion for Vox (Left bias) criticized conservatives, including Former President Donald Trump and Benny Johnson for describing the women’s team as “woke” and gloating over their elimination. It compared conservative discontent with the team to previous boycotts like Bud Light and the Barbie Movie. The writer attributed the upset to injuries and increased parity within world soccer.
Rapinoe Makes It Tough: An opinion writer for Fort Worth Star-Telegram (Center bias) said while they believe America should always cheer for its teams, players’ “graceless self-absorption… can make such cheering impossible.” The writer said U.S. star player Megan Rapinoe is committed “to a lifetime of disrespect for the country she supposedly represents,” and since America is so diverse, it’s “not unfair to expect those representing our country to avoid berating it.”
Don’t Blame Republicans: An opinion writer for National Review (Right bias) critiqued the media, particularly a recent piece by New Republic (Left bias), for blaming the politicization of women’s soccer on Republicans. The writer says the U.S. team, primarily Rapinoe, has been eager to start “political feuds” and use “incendiary language,” despite how many Americans it may alienate. The writer said they “don’t endorse rooting against” America, but conservative reactions to the team’s loss is a “culmination of years of efforts on the team’s part to cultivate that response.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
The right-wing backlash against the US women’s national soccer team, explainedHeaded into the Women’s World Cup, the US women’s national soccer team (USWNT) was aiming to make history and become the first team — men or women — to win three consecutive world cups. That all came crashing down this weekend when the top-ranked US lost in penalty kicks to Sweden in the round of 16, the first of the competition’s four knockout rounds. The final will take place on August 20.
Given the expectations of excellence that the USWNT has set since the sport started to flourish on the international stage —...
From the Center
Cheers over U.S. women’s soccer defeat highlight unfortunate divisionsI did not set an alarm in the wee predawn hours Sunday to watch the U.S. women’s team’s World Cup match against Sweden. But I cared enough to set the DVR to learn of their fate, aided by the gift of fast-forward, which paid dividends through a full game and extra time with zero scoring.
As the two sides prepared for the suddenly eventful prospect of penalty kicks, I wondered how many Americans were rooting for them to survive and how many wished for their defeat.
What a dreadful question...
From the Right
No, Republicans Did Not Politicize Women’s SoccerThe New Republic senior editor Alex Shephard set out to refute the claim, advanced by some on the Right, that the U.S. women’s soccer team’s 5-4 loss to Sweden on penalty kicks was an outgrowth of the team’s commitment to “wokeness.” In that effort, he does a workmanlike job of demonstrating why the team’s tactical decisions on the field are sufficient to explain Monday’s unsatisfying results.
Shephard does, however, take up the claim from “mediocre” former U.S. soccer player Alexi Lalas who called the women’s team “polarizing” to such an extent that it has...
AllSides Picks
September 16th, 2024
September 15th, 2024
September 13th, 2024
The Alliance for Citizen Engagement
September 13th, 2024