Hulu's 1619 Project Series Rekindles Debate on Slavery, American Revolution
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Hulu is airing a documentary series adapted from ‘The 1619 Project,’ a Pulitzer Prize-winning New York Times (Lean Left Bias) multimedia project that sparked controversy for claiming a motivation behind the American Revolution was colonists’ desire to preserve slavery in America.
Key Quote: In the opening essay for the project, project creator Nikole Hannah-Jones writes, “we may never have revolted against Britain if some of the founders had not understood that slavery empowered them to do so; nor if they had not believed that independence was required in order to ensure that slavery would continue.”
Fact? Hannah-Jones defended the claim in an interview with Forbes, stating, “we've all been indoctrinated into these myths about America and we've all been told a history that's not true.” A piece in CNN Opinion stated, “America remains collectively trapped in historical amber – enmeshed in cruel myths and violent falsehoods that perpetuate racial division, economic inequality, segregation and violence.”
Fiction? The Daily Caller (Right Bias) quoted American historian Gordon Wood calling the claim “just plain wrong,” and stating that the revolution “created the first antislavery movement in the history of the world.” James Bovard pointed to the northern colonies' lack of economic reliance on slavery to determine they “would not have risked their lives for its preservation.” In 2020, Politico (Lean Left Bias) published a piece by historian Leslie M. Harris, who was enlisted by the Times to fact-check the project and “vigorously disputed” Hannah-Jones's claim.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the LeftHow ‘The 1619 Project’ reveals democracy’s only hope for the future
The first two episodes of “The 1619 Project,” a documentary series which premiered on Hulu on Thursday, brings to life the Pulitzer Prize-winning New York Times multimedia project created by Nikole Hannah-Jones.
As the first two episodes of “The 1619 Project” make dramatically clear, “the relentless buying, selling, insuring, and financing” of Black people “would help make Wall Street and New York City the financial capital of the world.”
At the same time, these episodes also reveal how Black folks represent American democracy’s beating heart; that heart has helped fuel...
From the CenterCreator Nikole Hannah-Jones Explains Why ‘The 1619 Project’ Docu-Series Is Essential American History
“It’s impossible to understand the story of America without understanding the story of slavery and Black Americans,” says Nikole Hannah-Jones.
The journalist created The 1619 Project, a series of essays that reframes our country's history by showcasing how the contributions of Black Americans shaped our national narrative. Hannah-Jones was awarded the prestigious Pulitzer Prize in 2020 for her work on the project. The essays were also the subject of a podcast in 2020, and released in book form in 2021.
The 1619 Project takes its name from the year in...
From the RightTo vilify our founders, Hulu’s ‘1619’ ignores what actually sparked the American Revolution
The 1619 Project is back in the news with the release of the six-part Hulu series built around the claim that “nearly everything that has made America exceptional grew out of slavery.” Progressives have canonized the Nikole Hannah-Jones-led New York Times effort, which is being taught in more than 4,500 classrooms. But the project is riddled with faulty assumptions and factual errors that have been debunked across the ideological spectrum.
The 1619 Project’s most harebrained idea is that the American Revolution was fought to preserve slavery. Slavery was barbaric, especially...