Federal Judge Temporarily Pauses 'Unconstitutional' Parts of NJ Gun Law
Summary from the AllSides News Team
A federal judge in New Jersey granted a motion Monday to temporarily pause part of a new state gun law that limits the concealed carry of firearms.
The Details: The part of the law in question prohibits the public from carrying firearms in certain "sensitive" locations, even if they have a concealed-carry permit. Gun rights groups sued the state on the day of the law's passage, alleging that the limitations are unconstitutional.
For Context: State legislatures across the country have debated concealed-carry laws following the Supreme Court's ruling last summer that scaled back New York's restrictions on carrying guns outside the home.
Key Quotes: "The deprivation of Plaintiffs’ Second Amendment rights, as the holders of valid permits from the State to conceal carry handguns, constitutes irreparable injury, and neither the State nor the public has an interest in enforcing unconstitutional laws," Bumb wrote in her ruling. "We are disappointed by the Court’s ruling, which is inconsistent with the Second Amendment and will make New Jerseyans considerably less safe," state Attorney General Matthew J. Platkin said in a statement.
How the Media Covered It: Some right-rated sources, such as The Daily Caller, focused more on arguments from the judge and gun rights advocates about why the rule purportedly infringes on 2nd Amendment rights. Some left-rated sources, such as Politico, focused on the parts of the law that remained intact and framed the pause of the concealed carry rule as less siginificant.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Right
Federal Judge Rules That Parts Of New Jersey Gun Law Are UnconstitutionalA federal judge ruled Monday that part of New Jersey’s concealed carry gun law, which dictates where a concealed firearm can be carried, is unconstitutional.
District Judge Renée Marie Bumb placed a temporary restraining order on the law’s “sensitive places” restrictions, saying they violate the Second Amendment rights of New Jersey residents, according to the ruling. Bumb based her ruling on the belief that the state did not have the “historical tradition” of regulating where a concealed carry permit can be used.
“Plaintiffs have shown that Defendants will not be able to demonstrate...
From the Left
Federal judge temporarily blocks portions of New Jersey's new gun lawA federal judge on Monday temporarily blocked part of a newly-enacted New Jersey law that prohibits guns from being carried in certain parts of the state.
U.S. District Judge Renée Marie Bumb, sitting in Camden, issued a temporary restraining order for a section of the law that specifically bans guns from being carried in public libraries or museums, bars or restaurants that serve alcohol and entertainment facilities. One catch-all provision barring guns from being carried on private property where the owner did not explicitly grant permission was also blocked, as...
From the Center
Court Halts NJ's New Concealed-Carry LawA federal judge granted a motion to temporarily strike down a recently passed New Jersey law that limits the concealed carry of firearms. Monday's ruling marks a legal victory for the gun-rights groups who sued the state on the day of the law's passage.
The new measure prohibits the public from carrying firearms in certain "sensitive" locations, even if they have a concealed-carry permit. Gov. Phil Murphy signed the bill into law Dec. 22 — the same day the National Rifle Association (NRA) announced it would challenge it in court....
AllSides Picks
April 18th, 2024
April 18th, 2024