Is Diversity-Focused Casting Anti-Racist or Virtue Signaling?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Much discussion has been sparked by the casting of non-white actors in fantasy-genre film and television shows, most notably HBO’s “House of the Dragon” and Amazon Prime Video’s “The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.” Debates are waging regarding backlash to diversity-focused casting, with some accusing critics of racism, and others claiming that present efforts for diversity in media are performative and disingenuous.
In an article for Newsweek, Angie Speaks deemed the casting of black actors in “House of the Dragon” to be shallow attempts at broadening the show’s appeal, stating that it is not true representation when black actors are “stuck into explicitly white roles with no concern for plot or whether it makes sense.”
In a piece for RedState, Brandon Morse stated that criticism towards “woke entertainment” was not rooted in bigotry, but instead a distaste for message-first storytelling, labeling it predictable and “effectively just propaganda with a mask.”
In The Atlantic, Adam Serwer responded to Morse’s criticisms, accusing him of wanting “Jim Crow casting requirements” and claiming backlash from conservative outlets to stem from a desire to “convince the corporations that make television shows and films that their products will fail commercially if they do not conform to conservative politics.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Center
House of the Dragon's Diversity Casting Betrays the Diversity of Martin's UniverseHBO's House of the Dragon, the prequel to the hit show Game of Thrones, made headlines for its diversity casting, with Black actors being given major roles in the show. The headlines weren't all positive; the casting somewhat flew in the face of the plot, which revolves around the race-purity obsessed Targaryen family. It was jarring to many, including myself, to suddenly see Black actors portraying characters with Valyrian ancestry married into the Targaryen family fold, like Steve Toussaint, who portrays Lord Coryls Velaryon. But others extolled the decision, casting...
From the Right
The Reason Social Justice-Infected Shows Fail Isn't Racism, It's Actually Much SimplerThe age of woke entertainment built its castle on the sand and with every new attempt to build on it, the castle becomes more and more unstable. Studios reach for excuses as to why, and it typically involves blaming fans and viewers.
The list of social justice-infected movies and shows is a long one. Ghostbusters 2016, Netflix’s live-action Cowboy Beebop, Netflix’s live-action Resident Evil show, She-Hulk, Obi-Wan Kenobi, and now Amazon’s bastardization of Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings with its “Rings of Power” show.
Each of these shows abused the...
From the Left
Fear of a Black HobbitMaybe you’ve heard that people are mad about Black actors being cast in Lord of the Rings. Or Game of Thrones. Or maybe it was Star Wars. Or perhaps Thor. Wait, maybe it was Titans, or Superman. The Witcher? Or maybe you heard that people are angry that Black Panther got made in the first place, because Wakanda is fictional, unlike one of those fantasy countries authors seem to think will seem more mysterious if you add enough accents or apostrophes, like Warthéréth’rién. (I just made that up.) Maybe you’re...
AllSides Picks
March 27th, 2024
March 27th, 2024
Discuss & Debate race and racism
Building Trust by Building Together
April 04 at 10am PT / 1pm ET Living Room Conversations