Boston Children's Hospital Criticized Over Trans Youth Surgery Resources
Summary from the AllSides News Team
A prominent hospital's resources on gender transition procedures for children sparked criticism and claims of misinformation online.
Boston Children's Hospital (BCH), the first hospital in the U.S. with a youth "Gender Multispecialty Services" program, was accused of promoting and performing hysterectomies for young girls. A video on BCH's YouTube channel showed one of its doctors detailing "gender-affirming hysterectomies." The video, which was part of a longer series of BCH resources on transition procedures, is now hidden from the public.
A statement from the hospital Tuesday said it "does not—and will not—perform a hysterectomy as part of gender-affirming care on a patient under the age of 18" since it "requires a patient to be capable of consenting for themselves." It also said it had been targeted by "a large volume of hostile internet activity" and "threats of violence towards our clinicians and staff" in response to the video.
Right-rated sources covered the story more than left- and center-rated sources. Some on the right accused the hospital of advancing "illogical and destructive gender ideology" and suggested that the hospital performs hysterectomies for children. Left- and center-rated news outlets framed that as misinformation, and focused on "right-wing threats and harassment" against the hospital. Other sources, such as Epoch Times (Lean Right bias), highlighted BCH resources that suggest looser age requirements for other gender transition surgeries, such as vaginoplasty and chest augmentation.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Boston Children's Hospital faces threats over gender-affirming careFar-right activists have unleashed a torrent of threatening calls and emails against Boston Children's Hospital over its health care services for transgender youth — the latest in a broad effort against those who offer gender-affirming care.
Driving the news: The hospital is boosting security and working with law enforcement after receiving a barrage of online complaints and threats about its program for treating trans and nonbinary youth.
The program also offers genital surgeries for patients ages 18 and up. Far-right influencers and their followers are falsely claiming doctors are performing these surgeries on...
From the Right
Boston Children's Hospital Under Fire for Now-Deleted Video Promoting 'Gender-Affirming Hysterectomies' for Young GirlsBoston Children’s Hospital has faced intense backlash after promoting what it called “gender-affirming hysterectomies” for young girls who identify as transgender.
The since-removed video in question featured Dr. Frances Grimstad, who works for the hospital’s division of gynecology. In it, she explained the kinds of hysterectomies girls could undergo.
“A gender-affirming hysterectomy is very similar to most hysterectomies that occur,” the doctor said in the video clip unearthed by the popular Libs of TikTok account. “A hysterectomy itself is the removal of the uterus, the cervix — which is the...
From the Left
Right-wing groups hit Boston Children’s with barrage of threats over trans health programDoctors and other staff who care for transgender children at Boston Children’s Hospital are facing a barrage of threats and harassment that started last week with an online campaign, prompting the hospital to seek help from law enforcement and remove doctors’ names and images from its website.
The hospital, which in 2007 established the nation’s first pediatric and adolescent transgender health program, issued a statement late Tuesday saying that it “has been the target of a large volume of hostile internet activity, phone calls, and harassing emails including threats of...
AllSides Picks
April 17th, 2024
April 18th, 2024